Chiming in here. I'm not privy to all the behind-the-scenes details, but it would be my opinion that we kept Whitesell to keep the roster intact (Williams, Graves, Segu) and sacrificed a lot of the equity Oats and Hurley had built. Those two had built Buffalo into a desirable mid-major coaching position. This was a place that, clearly, a coach could win at and spring board his career. This hire will set us back. And unless things change quickly (either Whitesell turns it around or a change is made) we will burn all of that progress to the ground and have to restart.
Maybe I'm dreaming here, but I had visions of growing this thing. I truly felt that we could become, not a Gonzaga per se, but a VCU or a Wichita State. Perennial conference chanps with an occasional down year. The nation would know UB. But now, I truly struggle to see the light at the end of the tunnel now. I see another 18 - 22 win season for two more years and then being faced with the decision... is that good enough? 20 wins, some success in Cleveland, but likely not conference titles? I know it's early and I'm likely over-reacting, but I see Whitesell being very Reggie-esque. Again, 18 - 22 wins a year, an occasional trip to the championship in Cleveland but dreams of a run in the tournament or frankly, even getting there, have quickly faded.
Man... last year was fun. What if had not run into Tech in that round of 32? I guess we'll never know.